Market news, first published October 28, 2010. The forecasts below are kept as a dated record; what actually happened is in a dated section at the end.
In the fourth quarter of 2010 the outlook for the chip industry was cloudy for the rest of the year and into 2011. On October 27, 2010, EE Times reporter Mark LaPedus gathered five good and five bad signs for the IC market (Internet Archive copy) from analysts and research firms. Here is what they said, in short, and what came next.
The five good signs
- A strong 2010. Bill Jewell of Semiconductor Intelligence expected 2010 growth above 30 percent. Most forecasters saw growth slowing sharply in 2011 and 2012, but his firm thought those forecasts were too cautious.
- Microprocessors still growing. Semico Research projected the MPU market to grow 13.6 percent in 2011 to $45.7 billion.
- Healthy NAND flash pricing. VLSI Research reported that high-density NAND demand was strong and supply was tight, which kept average selling prices healthy.
- Broadcom beat expectations. A Benchmark analyst noted Broadcom's third-quarter revenue beat consensus and its fourth-quarter guidance pointed up, helped by mobile design wins and demand from Apple's iPhone and iPad.
- Solar outlook. Bloomberg New Energy Finance expected falling equipment costs and government support to lift U.S. solar capacity from about 1.4 GW to as much as 44 GW by 2020.
The second page of the article (Internet Archive copy) listed the bad signs.
The five bad signs
- Weak DDR3 spot market. VLSI Research described slow demand for mainstream DDR3 and falling spot prices.
- Hard disk shortages. Next Inning Research reported a shortage of higher-density notebook hard drives, as PC makers moved back to bigger drives once DRAM prices fell.
- Silicon Labs downgrade. An FBR analyst downgraded Silicon Labs after weak fourth-quarter guidance, pointing to customer inventory cuts and fading older product lines.
- Cautious chipmakers. A Barclays Capital analyst said Novellus heard a cautious tone from customers, with foundry and memory projects being pushed out.
- Equipment orders slowing. VLSI Research expected the book-to-bill ratio for IC equipment to fall below 1 in October 2010, while chipmakers such as TI warned of softer demand.
Why these signs matter
The list is a good example of how the chip cycle shows up in data before it shows up in annual totals. Memory spot prices react within weeks. Equipment book-to-bill tells you whether chipmakers are still adding capacity. Company guidance tells you what customers are ordering for the next quarter. Read together, they pointed to a strong 2010 followed by a much slower 2011, which is what happened.
Terms in plain words
- Spot market: memory bought and sold outside long-term contracts. Its prices move first when supply and demand shift.
- ASP (average selling price): revenue divided by units shipped.
- Book-to-bill: new orders divided by shipments in the same period. Above 1 means orders are growing faster than shipments.
- Guidance: a company's own forecast for the next quarter.
Deep dive: the numbers and details
This part holds the forecasts side by side and the actual results. Skip it if the overview is all you need.
The growth forecasts in October 2010
| Forecaster (as quoted) | 2011 growth | 2012 growth |
|---|---|---|
| WSTS and SIA (June 2010) | About 6% | 3% to 4% |
| Gartner and iSuppli (recent at the time) | About 5% | Under 2% |
| Semiconductor Intelligence | 9% | 8% |
What happened next
The Semiconductor Industry Association's year-end figures show how the forecasts turned out:
| Year | Worldwide sales | Change | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2010 | $298.3 billion | +31.8% | SIA, January 31, 2011 |
| 2011 | $299.5 billion | +0.4% | SIA, February 6, 2012 |
| 2012 | $291.6 billion | -2.7% | SIA, February 4, 2013 |
The "above 30 percent" call for 2010 was right. Every quoted forecast for 2011 and 2012 was too high, and the most optimistic one, 9 and 8 percent, missed by the widest margin. SIA's 2011 release named natural disasters in Japan and Thailand and a weak global economy as the main challenges of that year. The bad signs in the list (soft DRAM pricing, cautious customers, slowing equipment orders) turned out to be the better guide.
A quick check with the numbers
Had 2011 grown 6 percent, as WSTS and SIA forecast in June 2010, sales would have been about $298.3 billion x 1.06 = $316 billion. The actual figure was $299.5 billion, about $17 billion lower. Two years of 9 and 8 percent growth would have reached about $351 billion in 2012, against an actual $291.6 billion.
Reading leading indicators
- Book-to-bill: a ratio of 1.10 means $110 of new orders for every $100 shipped; 0.90 means orders are running 10 percent below shipments, so future shipments fall unless orders recover.
- Spot versus contract prices: spot prices are set trade by trade, contract prices are negotiated for a period, so the spot market shows a change in demand first.
- Inventory cuts: when customers draw down their own stock, chip orders fall by more than end demand, which is what the Silicon Labs note described.


This is all like looking at the crystal ball, but considering that stock market is making new highs and the bullish sentiment, 2011 will hopefully be more good than bad :)
ReplyDelete